Have you ever seen how difficult the promotion Rules for standard 9 in Maharastra HSC Board are?
When I was studying in 9th that was some 14 years ago, things used to be very simple, give one exam get certain marks then you pass. Now things have got extremely complex ( I dont know if it is tough, but for sure the rules are much much more complicated)
See for example- The languages have one passing criteria whereas Maths and Science have totally different.
If I go to explain the entire rule, it will need me to post another 3-4 page blog, so i wont dwell into details, but just to illustrate my point on complexity let me give one example.
Passing criteria for Maths -
There will be two sub subjects - Maths 1 and Maths 2
There will be two semesters - 1 and 2
In semester 1 - A student will be giving one Unit Test for each subject (Maths 1 and Maths 2) conducted out of 30 which will then be converted into 10,
then another 5 marks wil be awarded for homework/assginment - this makes it 10+5 = 15
After this there will be one exam at the end of semester 1 , which will be out of 60
Now 15 marks will be added to this 60 that will make it 75
Similiar computation will be done for semester 2 -
So semester 1 + semester 2 = 75 + 75 = 150
Same will be done for Maths 2
Now maths 1 and Maths 2 will be added to get the total to 300 and average of the two will be out of 150
A student will have to get 52 marks to pass Maths exam!!!!
Phew!!!!!!! How was it?
The system is so complex that many parents do not understand its working. Adding to the complexity is the concept of giving grace and promoting a student
I have discussed this matter with several principals on how this system actually helps to bring about improvements in the education level and I am yet to recieve a convincing answer to it.
I feel we should do away with such a complex evaluation sytem for High school education. And have a standard system throughout India with common curriculum and evaluation standards. A curriculum which is strong in content and evaluation system which is comprehensive yet simple in nature.
When I was studying in 9th that was some 14 years ago, things used to be very simple, give one exam get certain marks then you pass. Now things have got extremely complex ( I dont know if it is tough, but for sure the rules are much much more complicated)
See for example- The languages have one passing criteria whereas Maths and Science have totally different.
If I go to explain the entire rule, it will need me to post another 3-4 page blog, so i wont dwell into details, but just to illustrate my point on complexity let me give one example.
Passing criteria for Maths -
There will be two sub subjects - Maths 1 and Maths 2
There will be two semesters - 1 and 2
In semester 1 - A student will be giving one Unit Test for each subject (Maths 1 and Maths 2) conducted out of 30 which will then be converted into 10,
then another 5 marks wil be awarded for homework/assginment - this makes it 10+5 = 15
After this there will be one exam at the end of semester 1 , which will be out of 60
Now 15 marks will be added to this 60 that will make it 75
Similiar computation will be done for semester 2 -
So semester 1 + semester 2 = 75 + 75 = 150
Same will be done for Maths 2
Now maths 1 and Maths 2 will be added to get the total to 300 and average of the two will be out of 150
A student will have to get 52 marks to pass Maths exam!!!!
Phew!!!!!!! How was it?
The system is so complex that many parents do not understand its working. Adding to the complexity is the concept of giving grace and promoting a student
I have discussed this matter with several principals on how this system actually helps to bring about improvements in the education level and I am yet to recieve a convincing answer to it.
I feel we should do away with such a complex evaluation sytem for High school education. And have a standard system throughout India with common curriculum and evaluation standards. A curriculum which is strong in content and evaluation system which is comprehensive yet simple in nature.